Showing posts with label people smuggling.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label people smuggling.. Show all posts

Friday, June 13, 2014

                                           Are you blaming me?


News tonight reports hundreds of women and small children, some children unaccompanied, getting into the United States illegally then handing themselves in and wanting to be allowed to stay. The same sort of thing happens in Australia, although it's a bit harder because we don't have land borders with any other nation. They come by boat or plane instead. And wherever it happens, sanctimonious opportunists follow, calling themselves caring people by claiming the moral high ground.
Now real refugees have a need for help, but like any other worthy cause, this one gets exploited unscrupulously and self righteously. I would never want to be unsympathetic to those in real need, but I won't be bullied and morally blackmailed by humbug; and there are some dishonest claims being made in regard to illegal arrivals.
The illegal arrivals, whether genuine refugees or not, are housed, not abandoned in the wilderness.. In the U.S. case reported tonight, emergency accommodation has been set up. And we see various self styled commentators loudly condemning the U.S. Government because the accommodation is not five star. I'm using an analogy here. Suppose fifty people turned up at someone's house, wanting to be taken in, and the house owner is criticized because they can't find a bedroom and a banquet for all of them? Why are they being treated as though these people were their responsibility?
The U.S. Government is not responsible for the citizens of other nations. If they enter the country in an illicit way, so that it is not possible or mandatory to plan for them, why is the U.S. Government to blame? It's the same with our Australian Federal Government. Some fifty thousand people arrived by boat before a change of government and a new policy that put a stop to it. Fifty thousand extra people are not easy to cater for without proper notice and planning, and our government is NOT responsible for the citizens of other nations. If they are genuine refugees, which past experience shows they may NOT be at all, then they have claims under the U.N. Charter. But it is absurd sanctimony for critics to stand there abusing the government because it can't lay out a lavish reception for them. We have our own poor and disaster  victims to look after too. Some of the unauthorized arrivals are wannabe migrants trying to jump the queue by claiming refugee status. They do not have a true and legitimate claim to residence in the country they enter. And even where the arrivals are genuine refugees, the country in which they arrive may have its own resources stretched providing for them. Both the countries discussed here have suffered major natural disasters, and their own  citizens need support and financial assistance to recover. We have to consider those before someone tells us we have to look after thousands of other countries' citizens as well. People who enter without permission or notice should not think that facilities are all laid out for them as a matter of right. The worst part of this is that the attitudes of people become hardened. I would never want to deny someone in real need, if I could help them, but I won't be told that I have to give up our own family's stuff to some outsider who demands it by gate crashing the country without permission. Self righteous critics walking around sounding off are an insult to genuine social conscience - in my humble opinion.

Saturday, November 2, 2013

Have I got this right?

If anyone reads this, I'd be glad to hear if you can tell  me something I don't know. The issue is, refugees. In Australia, as in the United States, we find people trying to get into the country hoping for a better life (or on the run from something?) and claiming in some cases to be refugees. There is an ongoing argument about how we should respond, should we let them all in or turn back those who can't clearly show refugee status. It's happening in Southern Europe, too, people attempting to get to Italy from Africa by boat - sometimes with tragic results, like mass drowning when a boat sinks, or deaths in the desert when they did not manage to make one part of the journey safely. There are those who say we would solve the problem if we just opened our borders and made it easier for them to get here. Now as a Christian, I would never want to be found lacking proper compassion for the desperate. But there is good evidence that some of the would-be migrants are not refugees, they are not forced to flee from something, they simply want to get somewhere they hope life will be better. But should we just open our borders? I'm wondering: if the U.S. let everyone in who wanted to come, half the population of South America would cross the border, the U.S. population would double in five years and the place would become exactly what the migrants are trying to escape from. It would be critically overcrowded, the infrastructure would not cope, people would be living in desperation without adequate medical services, employment or drinking water, and order would break down with clashes between ethnic groups or gangs preying on the desperate.  In Australia, likewise,  if we simply said "Come who may" the inrush from places like Sri Lanka, Vietnam, China et al would overwhelm the country and cause huge problems with infrastructure, maintaining living standards and stopping violent clashes over scarce resources. So despite the moral blackmail directed at those who do not believe in unrestricted migration, it is pure necessity to keep it in check. If I'm wrong, someone feel free to tell me HOW, not just insist THAT, which proves nothing at all.
Just recently with a change of government the number of illegal arrivals by sea has dropped right off. If the respectable press is to be believed, some people from Iran and Sri Lanka who travelled to Indonesia trying to get to Australia by boat have agreed to return to their homelands. So they cannot be as desperate as they claimed. That would indicate that spurious claims to be refugees were made by some who were just economic migrants, trying to jump the queue and not go through legal channels.   
The movement of refugees around the world is inherently dangerous, and the things that cause them to be refugees need to be counteracted. Simply offering them places in another country does not stop others being made refugees. Indeed it can give rise to an evil industry in people smuggling, which has led to the migrants being tricked into getting onto unsafe boats and sent to sea where they sink. If the United Nations was any good, could it not stop the upheavals and pressures that drive people from their homes?
If you can see that I'm wrong here, show me how. It seems to me that some deceitful moral blackmail and general humbug has been generated around this issue,  by those claiming the moral high ground advocating for 'refugees' and not thinking clearly about the facts of it all.